Group research: which concrete groups to test first
Group research: which concrete groups to test first
Written 2026-11-18 (Fable subagent, web search) for 2027-strategy.md. Numbers are rough: mostly third-party trackers or a few years old. Scores 1–5 are judgement; the evidence column is what searches found. Community self-promotion rules not checked.
| Group | Size | Reach | Fit | Inside/outside the milieu | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Meaning-crisis listeners | 4 | 3 | 5 | Inside | Vervaeke about 132k YouTube (tracker); Hagens about 132k YouTube (estimate), 14k+ Substack |
| Metamodern / liminal web | 1–2 | 5 | 5 | Inside | No counts; described as fragmented or absorbed (Substack) |
| EA / rationalists | 2 | 3 | 2 | Inside (edge) | EA Forum 11,419 logged-in users in 2025, about 1,800 engaged, flat (CEA) |
| Collapse-aware seeking hope | 4 | 4 | 4 | Outside | r/collapse about 500k, r/CollapseSupport about 25k (undated); Deep Adaptation Facebook about 10k (2020); Postdoom free weekly calls; resilience.org takes submissions |
| Burnt-out climate and impact workers | 3 | 4 | 4 | Outside | Work on Climate Slack about 35k (Hive Index, June 2026); 62% burnout among sustainability practitioners (n=159, Oxford Brookes); Climate Coffee about 30 cities |
| Spiritual-but-not-religious / post-church | 5 | 2 | 4 contemplative, 2 exvangelical | Outside (contemplative end borders the milieu) | 22% of US adults SBNR, only 11% of them in a religious community (Pew 2023); On Being's The Pause 261k; Rohr daily meditations 270k+ (CAC, 2017); r/exchristian 66k (2020) |
| Regenerative / community-builders | 3 | 3 | 3 | Outside | Transition: about 1,050 groups mapped, about 500 recently active, 80+ countries (map) |
| Solarpunk (added) | 4 | 4 | 3–4 | Outside | r/solarpunk 200k+ (undated) |
Fit and risk (judgement unless linked)
- Collapse-aware: the need is explicit; 56% of 16–25s in ten countries agreed "humanity is doomed" (Lancet survey, 2021). r/collapse may read "renaissance" as false hope; support and post-doom corners are the better entry.
- Climate and impact workers: burnout well evidenced; wanting a civilisational story, not just rest, is inference. Spiritual language may read as unserious in a professional Slack.
- Spiritual-but-not-religious: manifesto language fits the contemplative end best. Big venues are gated institutions, so reach is via Instagram and Substack. Exvangelical spaces are trauma-focused and likely wary of a "movement".
- Regenerative: practical doers, little online density; poor match for a YouTube-led test.
- Solarpunk: already wants a hopeful future story; young, visual, left-anarchist; expect scepticism of spiritual and "civilisation" language.
- EA and rationalists: small, flat, likely to mark down movement and spiritual language.
Recommended four: meaning-crisis listeners (inside, baseline); collapse-aware seeking hope; burnt-out climate and impact workers; contemplative spiritual-but-not-religious (all outside).
Alternatives: easy-first (metamodern, meaning-crisis, collapse-aware, regenerative): fastest signal, but only one strong outside test. All outside (collapse-aware, climate workers, contemplatives, solarpunk): cleanest gate test, no baseline, slower.
Drop or change: drop EA and rationalists; fold metamodern into meaning-crisis; cut the tech half of burnt-out workers (no named place they gather); keep contemplatives, park exvangelicals; park regenerative until there is an offline format.
Not opened: a Second Renaissance forum thread, "Lifeitself - engaging with other communities", which may hold prior thinking.