What success means in 2027: the engagement ladder
What success means in 2027: the engagement ladder
Written 2026-11-19 during the 2027 LTP, to settle a question that had to come before the 2027 goal. Sources: Rufus's comments on the goal and a subagent analysis. Sits under the top-level strategy; feeds the 2027 strategy.
In short
- Success in 2027 is regulars, not followers. A regular is someone who keeps coming back and says "this story is mine". That is our version of product–market fit: in the funnel diagram, the bottom of the first funnel, where people "have the words … and the belonging".
- Reach and depth together. We still aim to double reach (about 10,000 to about 20,000 followers and subscribers), because it feeds everything below. But reach is the means; regulars, and the catalysts among them, are the result.
- A build year, not a learning year. We have a decade of experience. 2027 builds the path from reach to regulars to catalysts and counts each step.
The question behind it
Before we could set a 2027 goal we had to answer: do we push the top of the funnel (followers, online awareness) and assume it converts, or focus a level down, on people who are interested and coming through? And what is the "customer who bought the product" for a movement?
The debate, and how it resolves
Two diagnoses were on the table:
- Too few people find the story. The top-level strategy names the core problem as "no distribution engine": after ten years going deep, the story isn't told simply or broadcast widely.
- A committed core is how movements spread. Rufus's sense: people who go deeper, become catalysts, run local and topical groups and talk to others are how this actually spreads, more than lots of content online. It is also what sets us apart from talking heads on the internet.
Both are right, at different rungs. The top-level "engine" already means broadcasting and catalysts. Research on movements points the same way (cited from memory, not checked): the associations that build the most activism both mobilise (broad, light asks) and organise (relationships and real responsibility) (Hahrie Han); leaders develop leaders, and story travels through relationships (Marshall Ganz); costly, identity-laden commitments spread through repeated contact in close groups, not through broadcast (Damon Centola). Broadcast on its own builds an audience: channels in our field with 100,000+ subscribers after 5–8 years are audiences, not movements.
What follows for 2027:
- Reach is the part we control least: about 2x is likely, more only if a piece breaks out (growth research).
- Turning followers into regulars is the part we control most. Even 1% of 10,000 followers is 100 regulars, and we don't yet try to convert deliberately (assumption, to check with the December count).
- So: keep publishing finished work; give every piece one clear next step; welcome newcomers personally; give anyone who returns a role; and keep growing catalysts, which is already happening (below).
The ladder
| Rung | Who | What we count |
|---|---|---|
| Reached | Saw or heard one piece | Views, listens, reach of each piece |
| Following | Opted in to hear again | Followers and subscribers on each platform (about 10,000 now, counting some people twice) |
| Engaged | Reads or listens most times | Newsletter regular openers; YouTube returning viewers; downloads per episode |
| Joined | Showed up once | First Global Connection Call; joined Discord or the forum; signed up for a course |
| Regular | Keeps coming back; "I'm part of this scene" | 3+ calls in a quarter, or a course completed, or active in Discord or the forum each month; plus a one-question pulse, "is this story yours?", so people who hold it through the podcast or newsletter count too |
| Catalyst | Brings others in or hosts | A named list: hosts a call breakout, a circle, or a local or topical group; or has brought two or more people |
Below this is the second funnel, going deeper: pockets and local groups. Catalysts are where the first funnel hands over to the second.
Why regulars, not joined, as the anchor. Joining is a first purchase; coming back, and calling the story yours, is fit. Joined is easier to count but says little about whether the story landed. The pulse question widens "regular" beyond live events.
Places people hang out (where "joined" and "regular" happen): the Global Connection Call, Discord, and the forum.
Catalysts already exist. The Acorn catalyst circle ran its first three-month cohort from July 2026 (Acorn 1); Series 2 is running now, and a second cohort (Acorn 2) is being designed. In 2027 catalysts help set up and run local and topical groups.
The 2027 goal this gives (draft)
By December 2027, about 300 regulars (they keep coming back and call the story theirs), about 30 of them catalysts who bring in or host others, and the audience they come from doubled to about 20,000.
300 and 30 are placeholders until we count the baseline. If today's number of regulars is about 50, the goal becomes 3–4x whatever we find.
Count in December 2026
- Unique Global Connection Call attendees over the last 12 weeks, and how many came three or more times.
- Discord and forum members, and how many are active each month.
- 2026 course sign-ups and completions.
- Current catalysts (Acorn).
- The overlap between these, matched by email.
- From now on, "how did you hear of us?" on every sign-up, so we can see which reach turns into regulars.
Open
- Whether to ask people to formally sign up as members or supporters, or keep membership implicit (showing up).
- How to run the "is this story yours?" pulse without making it a chore.