What success at the bottom of funnel 1 means: ladder and anchor for the 2027 goal

Written 2026-11-19 by a Fable subagent for the 2027 LTP (2027-ltp.md), at Rufus's request, after his comments on the goal. Read-only analysis; the movement literature (Han, Ganz, Centola) is cited from memory, not checked. Numbers are provisional until a December 2026 baseline count.

Recommendation

Anchor the 2027 goal on regulars: people who keep showing up in live spaces. Reach is the feeder to double; catalysts are the leading sign of funnel 2. Suggested goal: "By December 2027, 300 people are regulars in Seeds of Renaissance (they keep showing up and call the story theirs), 30 of them are catalysts who bring or host others, and the audience they come from has doubled to about 20,000." The 300 and 30 are placeholders until the baseline count.

The debate: both diagnoses are right, at different rungs

  • The top level is ambiguous, not wrong. "No distribution engine" reads as broadcast, but its own Spread row defines the engine as broadcast plus catalysts, and it lists "community undefined" (cause C) as a cause of no movement and no vanguard. Rufus's instinct is the second half of the same engine, which the top level defers to 2028.
  • The movement literature supports combining them. Han: the associations that build the most activism both mobilise (broad, low-ask reach) and organise (relationships, real responsibility). Ganz: growth comes from leaders who develop other leaders, and story travels through relationships. Centola: costly, identity-laden commitments spread through repeated contact in clusters, not weak-tie broadcast. Community-led growth: content creates awareness; community converts and retains.
  • Broadcast alone gives an audience. The comparables in the growth research (Hagens, Vervaeke, Rebel Wisdom) have 100k+ subscribers after 5–8 years and are not movements ("talking heads").
  • Reach is what SoR controls least (likely about 2x, more only with a breakout). Conversion is what it controls most: 1% of about 10,000 followers becoming regulars is 100 people. Assumption: today's conversion is well below what a deliberate path would give.

Where 2027 effort goes (a build year, not a learning year): keep publishing finished work (the 2x plan, the top of the funnel); one ask on every piece, come to the Global Connection Call; personal follow-up for newcomers and a role for anyone who returns (host a breakout, welcome people, start a circle), since responsibility turns participants into activists (Han); a small catalyst cohort in 2027, which pulls part of the top level's 2028 move M4 forward and so needs Rufus's explicit yes.

The ladder

RungDefinitionCountable signal
ReachedSaw or heard one pieceViews, listens, Reel reach
FollowingOpted in to hear againFollowers and subscribers (about 10,000, with overlaps)
EngagedReads or listens most timesNewsletter regular openers; YouTube returning viewers; downloads per episode
JoinedShowed up live onceFirst call attendance (Luma); Discord join; course enrolment
RegularKeeps coming back; "I'm part of this scene"3+ calls in a quarter, or a course completed, or posting in Discord monthly; optionally a one-question pulse ("this story is mine")
CatalystBrings or hosts othersNamed list: hosted a breakout, circle or local meetup, or brought 2+ people

Joined is the purchase; Regular is product–market fit (repeat use plus referral), so Regular is the bottom of funnel 1. The Regular-to-Catalyst rate is the movement-fit test that separates SoR from an audience. Local groups and pockets stay in funnel 2. 300 is 1.5% of a 20,000 audience; if the baseline is about 50, restate the goal as 3–4x.

Count in December 2026

  • Unique call attendees over the last 12 weeks, and how many came 3+ times.
  • Discord members and monthly posters.
  • 2026 course enrolments and completions.
  • Overlap across these, matched by email.
  • A "how did you hear of us?" field on Luma registration, so reach and depth can be linked.

Assumptions: Luma and Zoom keep per-person attendance and Discord shows active posters; conversion, not awareness, is the weaker link today (the December count would confirm or overturn it); team time can shift toward hosting and follow-up.