Draft he was reacting to: "By Dec 2027 one core line has passed the fit bar with at least one group outside our circle, and owned reach is about 2x (followers and subscribers; 5x only if the gate passes and a piece breaks out), so the 2028 engine starts on evidence", with CSFs: one core line; finished work goes out; pieces travel; read fit per group; people can go further.

  • There's something more than reaching more people: people going deeper, coming to the courses and the community calls. It's even a debate whether that should be the priority.
  • The big debate: what should we prioritise? What matters is people who are relatively deeply engaged, who then become catalysts, spread the message, run local groups and talk to people.
  • His sense: you need that committed core; that is how things actually spread, rather than loads of stuff online. But that's a debate, and a researchable question we don't know the answer to: what is the best way to build a movement, or the best way for us to learn right now? Almost a product–market fit question, but for movement building.
  • Doesn't understand "the outside group takes up the core" or the goal about the outside group; doesn't know what it means. We may want to see more local groups. Confused on a bunch of this; it may go back to deeper things in the overall strategy or the SCQ.
  • CSF5 is good; the CSFs are not bad. Possibly something more about people. How it spreads may be not just word of mouth but fairly organic; open question. We don't really know how to make it spread.
  • We don't really understand why we've been so poor at attracting followers. Around a decade, about 2,000 on Instagram and 3,000 on YouTube, partly because we didn't put things out for a long time, particularly during COVID (2020–21), when we were focused on other things.

Second round (reply to goal options A, B, C)

Options shown: A, a learning year that grows the core (more people go deeper and some bring others; we learn which routes grow the committed core); B, depth first; C, reach and depth together. Recommended A, with the objection that the top level names "no distribution engine" as the core problem.

  • There is a strategic decision to make before the LTP, and that's why the goal is hard. Do we pursue top of the funnel (followers, awareness online) and assume it converts down? Or focus a level down, on people who are relatively interested and coming through, with some measure of, not membership, but people who are affiliated?
  • We need a definition of that: supporters, different levels of engagement, and measures of each. Would prefer reach and depth together.
  • Not a "learning year". We already know a lot: around a decade, and we've known this for three years. Our general feeling is that more people have to find out about this.
  • Gets the point of A: more people go deeper and some bring others; that is also what distinguishes us from talking heads on the internet.
  • Asked for a Fable subagent on the objection to A: a good background debate. We said the problem is no distribution engine; what is actually the problem, and why? We don't have measures of the kinds of people we want. More than followers, but what other kinds of membership or participation do we want to define? The brand documents talk about people building Gardens of Change or starting local groups. Measures might be people showing up in the more committed places, coming to local groups.
  • OK with A. The objection may be a CSF: we're both doing this and learning. The thing to resolve now: what is our definition of success, the equivalent of people buying the product, product–market fit?
  • Two things: building the movement or general awareness, and people going deeper and starting pockets. Our sense is that right now we want to build the upper of the two funnels in the funnel diagram (2R user flow, June 2026).
  • The upper funnel's goal: people who feel belonging, who feel the narrative is theirs, identify with it, have words for what they feel. A measure: people becoming catalysts, becoming members or joiners, or some way of evaluating that. The other part is top-of-funnel reach, but first identify what we really want at the bottom of the first funnel. That wants to be really clear now.

Third round (reply to the current reality draft)

On reach (his guess):

  • We don't publish regularly. As he understands it, that is a huge deal.
  • We don't have guests who are popular on the podcast, or get guests to share with their own following.
  • We don't have exactly the right content.
  • Evidence: a recent piece on Ivan Illich took off (about 18k views) and brought in about 200 subscribers. A random piece about 1.5 years ago went viral (SEO done well) and brought in about 1.5k subscribers.
  • His feeling: there are 50 small things we could do better that would add up to a massive change: posting more, and doing the small things better (SEO, covers and so on).
  • Underneath that: a lack of focus on, and optimisation of, marketing and content production by the core team.

On conversion:

  • We do OK, but we don't coordinate or support those who come through very well, and we don't have a standard, well-oiled path in to contribute.
  • We don't ask for financial support, we don't ask for resharing, we don't build community engagement online by engaging with people, and we don't post regularly in a more community sense on platforms.

Overall:

  • We don't apply ourselves strategically and systematically to building a following or building a community. Partly because Sylvie has no interest in this and Rufus was less focused on it (much more so now); partly a lack of capacity; partly not having the story sorted, which we now do.

Fourth round (reply to the core conflict cloud)

  • A team is already being set up to run this system, particularly to optimise marketing and post-production; that is central. So it doesn't need three months of Rufus alone; he can help run it with Uriel for three months.
  • Steps 2 (AI and templates; market finished work first) and 3 (write the routine down): yes.
  • Step 4: there is already a lead and a podcast manager plus more, so quite a bit of capacity.
  • History: we had one person about half-time across both comms and community, so very little capacity. Now about 1.5 FTE on marketing and communications, including a content lead (Uriel) and someone dedicated to the podcast (Amanda). That doubles, if not triples, capacity, and AI makes a huge difference.
  • The injection makes sense overall; a really good tension to identify.
  • Next: list the main conflicts, then decide which to work through in detail.