Life Itself v3 SCQH: why update?

#todo incorporate) analysis in Sep 2021 Strategy Review Sep 2021 [WIP]

SCQH

Situation

Last major version of Life Itself (v2) was in 2018-2020. This was a major advance (and the birth of “Life Itself” as previously named Art Earth Tech). In short: pragmatic utopians for a radically wiser, weller world and it starts with pioneer pockets piloting that future and engaging with broader society. At high level ended up with two distinct though complementary streams of starting hubs and catalyzing big vision conversation. On the ground, this meant a network of hubs on one hand and the institute on the other, with some implicit community (e.g. gatherings, events, people we knew), plus ad-hoc courses and initiatives.

Complication

In short, the main offer (Hubs) isn’t working (as planned), other main offer (Institute) didn’t fund and got limited traction and more generally Life Itself itself isn’t very clear (or too broad) e.g. re audience, voice etc; also too little wood behind too many arrows e.g. did calls and then stopped, did hangouts and then stopped, did possibility now and then stopped; there has been a consistent doubt about doing “community” stuff as w/o a concrete associated project or strong theme it won’t work (and lack that project or strong theme).

  • Hubs did not work so well: intentional communities are hard, hubs are too early in process (need a community first, or a good filter etc) and need to emerge from community (you can’t engineer them). In short:
    • Hard to do
    • Hard to engineer
    • Hard to find people
  • Not enough focus on exactly what groups we are looking for: pragmatic utopians can cover a lot of ground and whilst sounds good … what’s distinctive??
    • Hard to find the “others” but getting easier and have more of a sense now (though not yet reflected in messaging) e.g. from ecosystem mapping, from evolution of the “space”
      • What do these “others” look like
  • Institute didn’t work very well: did not get any funding. Maybe not a match for LK skills/approach.
  • In summary: too high level in our brand and our offer and not specific enough in our audience (i.e. in both call to actions and especially in topics) and hubs not working (partly as a result of that, partly because hard and too early)

Question: what is our new strategy?

What are the audience(s) (plus their interests / job stories) core to a nucleus of pragmatic utopian ecosystem and how do we revise our theme/offer and brand (and “lower-level” strategy) to reflect this … so that we can get more pioneers and community and get to the next stage of the flywheel?

Question in coggle is different: what's not working or missing with our current strategy/brand, what is our new strategy especially at the “how” level and what is our offering and brand so that in the next 10y we create a self-organizing dynamic community of integrated, rigorous, action-oriented changemakers?

Hypothesis

  • High level strategy largely unchanged, though clarified the kibbhuddistic ecosystem model. Pragmatic utopianism movement comes out of an kibbuddhist ecosystem etc
  • [Key!] Focal audience / topic: multidimensional (integral) ontological growth with rigorous, empirical and practical/embodied approach
    • Growth / development of “being / ego / consciousness”
    • Multi-dimensional
    • Multi-scale: personal, collective, societal
    • Integrated (both the dimensions and at scale)
  • Move towards being a hybrid online/offline (hubs, courses) community with a focus on online.
    • Take inspiration from lesswrong, finders etc
  • We have two core offers
    • Community for rigorous approach to transformation / getting wiser personally and collectively
      • [≤ supported by] [portal] (? A curated space for the twelve tribes of transformation everything from permaculture to mindfulness to)
      • [≤ supported by] [newsletter]
      • [supports =>] research, activism, hubs, Deliberately Developmental Programs …
    • Deliberately developmental programs - Residencies, Programs
      • [supports / leads to] => incubator => hubs
      • ≤ …
  • Key point: trying to find the “passionate” users, dense network, product market fit.

Changes

  • Develop Gateway info offerings plus “sangha” for advanced seekers / emerging ecosystem. Connected to deliberately developmental programs (DDP) and Hub generation
  • Focus on DDP rather than hubs (and long-term intentional community) per se. Hubs develop on a more bottom-up basis e.g. Hub is run by a team who self-organize. Life Itself not also a landlord etc
  • Institute was deprioritized in “core” for now (we don’t have resource plus not closing funding). Evolve to self-organizing “Labs” with a tighter focus, more plausible funding routes and in a quasi-independent setup
    • Big vision put on hold for now until we have more bandwidth etc … though big vision is one of the things that “sangha” likes to discuss and act on.

Brainstorm

🚚 hoisted SCQH - In a nutshell (v2)

  • Situation: Strategy and brand from 2018-2020 (that was a big advance): transition to wiser, weller world and it starts with pioneer pockets piloting that future and engaging with broader society etc.
    • Network of Hubs (aka intentional communities)
    • [Community - here and there way e.g. gatherings, events]
    • [Courses]
  • Complication:
    • Hubs did not work so well: intentional communities are hard, hubs are too early in process (need a community first, or a good filter etc) and need to emerge from community (you can’t engineer them).
      • Hard to do
      • Hard to engineer
      • Hard to find people
    • Not enough focus on exactly what groups we are looking for
      • Pragmatic utopians can cover a lot of ground
      • Sounds good … and … what’s distinctive??
      • Hard to find the “others” but getting easier and have more of a sense now (though not yet reflected in messaging) e.g. from ecosystem mapping, from evolution of the “space”
        • What do these “others” look like
    • In summary: too high level in our brand and our offer and not specific enough in our audience (i.e. in both call to actions and topics – especially topics) and hubs not working (partly as a result of that, partly because hard and too early)
  • Question: what are audience(s) (plus their interests / job stories) core to a nucleus of pragmatic utopian ecosystem and how do we revise our theme/offer and brand (and “lower-level” strategy) to reflect this?
  • Hypothesis:
    • [Key!] Focal audience / topic: multidimensional (integral) ontological growth with rigorous, empirical and practical/embodied approach
      • Growth / development of “being / ego / consciousness”
      • Multi-dimensional
      • Multi-scale: personal, collective, societal
      • Integrated (both the dimensions and at scale)
    • Move towards being a hybrid online/offline (hubs, courses) community with a focus on online.
    • Take inspiration from lesswrong, finders etc

SCQH brainstorm v1

Situation

  • v2 of Life Itself emerged starting at Autumn 2018 (sprint in Berlin) and culminating in SCQH in June 2019. Reflected in new SCQH and plan
    • Pioneering culture with coliving: Focus on finding pioneers with routes via hubs and (lesser extent) hiring
    • Big vision and shifting narratives with cultural activism and contemplation tank implemented via the institute and various events and activities
  • Potential for something much better/wiser + things profoundly not working
    • Transition to a new onto-social paradigm needed
      • Inner and outer transformation, with primacy for inner
        • Transition starts with pockets of pioneers (networked?)
          • Create a network of resilient flourishing communities …
            • Given pioneer groups are minority need to start in pockets (micro-regions)
              • To sustain a new way of being/operating need to live (and/or work) together in community
                • Create hubs (and businesses) piloting (and evolving the new approach)
  • Brand narrative 2020: focused on the high level. Pragmatic utopians
    • Ordinary people choosing an extra-ordinary path
    • Being changes everything. Spearhead a waking up, growing up, cleaning up culture. Make politics cool again to address collective challenges. These are key steps to a wiser, weller world for all beings.
    • What and How: We build a better, wiser future, now, through culture. We do this via spaces, a culture and a community – by pioneering our own and by allying with others to transform wider society.
  • Current audience, job stories and offers from 2020 https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/136Rp8OBEoeE-cMk6-TIU4p1PIuTIE5EUDnQFz8SWDas/edit
    • Did do the hub
    • Other major area was almost policy offers and think-tank (not so listed in that diagram)
  • Ecosystem mapping has got some traction (and potentially funding)
  • General space(s) have evolved in last 3-5y
    • Pandemic
    • Climate crisis worsening
    • Political polarization not going away
    • “Emerging ecosystem” more emerged (though also fracturing)
  • Community: …
  • Resources: Have approx 50-100k internal funding a year atm plus some donated time (Rufus)
    • Have started to have some funding especially around ecosystem stuff

Complication

In short, the main offer (Hubs) isn’t working (as planned), other main offer (Institute) didn’t fund and got limited traction and more generally Life Itself itself isn’t very clear (or too broad) e.g. re audience, voice etc; also too little wood behind too many arrows e.g. did calls and then stopped, did hangouts and then stopped, did possibility now and then stopped; there has been a consistent doubt about doing “community” stuff as w/o a concrete associated project or strong theme it won’t work (and lack that project or strong theme).

  • Hubs not quite working [in what way] TODO: link analysis on this
    • Landlord / tenant dynamic
    • Too optimistic about dynamics and complexities of intentional living etc
    • Scaling is hard and slow
    • Need ontological development / filtration to make it work
  • Slow finding pioneers and growing community in general … and it is only by finding a committed and expanding core of participants that Life Itself can fulfil on its vision
    • We had neglected community activity to some degree for 2y
    • Offers are not in line with the community we want to build or framed well in that context (e.g. Web3 to some extent)
    • User journeys have been unclear so far (except for maybe ecosystem map)
    • People who do engage e.g. around ecosystem generally were not given any clear opportunity to engage
    • No rigorous framework for finding pioneering and integrating them into our community
    • None of our offers have been things that people would interact with on a regular basis (except podcast) - note that the Web3 podcast took off
    • The core of people we are trying to attract is difficult to locate and attract
      • Filtration is hard
      • Our reach is small at the moment
  • Life Itself brand very broad and not very clear on who we want to engage which makes it difficult to present well etc
    • We are like an octopus - many arms of Life Itself
  • Institute not finding funding and struggling with a focus
  • For a small organization we are doing too many things (especially as core founders have a small child etc!)
    • What are we doing that is really pushing the needle of our mission?
  • Our current offers need to evolve (why? What’s not working about them?)
    • What are our current offers? Hubs and think pieces (?)
    • We need to think more about succession - putting up a think piece on a website where few people visit is not the first stage of succession. AKA how do we bring people in first, give them a taste, make them stay.
  • We don’t have an existing large user base … from which to recruit

What’s not working/changed:

  • Conscious coliving communities thesis not working as well as we would like and focus on "conscious (coliving) communities" may be too high level (should focus on "conscious network" (first?))

  • Strategy ends “too high up” e.g. atm with “creating a network of resilient communities pioneering the future” with next level down being creating conscious coliving communities (ie. hubs)

    • we don’t have a detailed enough how, i.e. our current strategy is too high level. To caricature it would be like saying our strategy is “save the world” and no detail on how. Or, we’re going to win the war … but how.
    • Roughly we currently say we need a transition to a new paradigm (limited details on new paradigm), primacy of being, build an ecosystem pioneering that (proximate and engaged with wider society etc), conscious coliving communities …
  • Hubs are not working

    • Hard to find critical mass of “right type of of people”
    • Who want to live together
    • And do so successfully
    • Financially difficult
    • Complex dynamics …
  • Institute not working (as well as we would like): depending on funding etc.

  • => Hubs are perhaps still too high level e.g. need a community first, need hubs to arise organically, may be other activities that are needed

  • We know more about the ecosystem(s) TODO (and what does that imply)

CurrentIssuesProposed
StrategySCQH: community of pragmatic utopians.The “what kind” of e.g. hubs, future paradigm not answered clearly enough. Hubs thesis didn’t pan out (too early, not enough pool of people)
Brand
Offers

Question

What's not working or missing with our current strategy/brand, what is our new strategy especially at the “how” level and what are our offerings and brand so that in the next 10y we create a self-organizing dynamic community of integrated, rigorous, action-oriented changemakers?

What is our updated strategy/brand (especially “how” and audience) so that we can get more pioneers and community and get to the next stage of the flywheel

[that incorporates our learning and engages more intensively (and more widely?) in a concrete and compelling way?]

  • What is our refinement of our “high level” SCQH Ans: not much …
  • What is our meso level?
  • What is the low level SCQH / vision
  • What are our offers etc

https://coggle.it/diagram/Y3IJZ_nDY3PfaFPG/t/life-itself-v3-strategy-revision-what-is-level-so-that

Hypothesis

(cf Strategy Stream What form there?)

  • High level strategy largely unchanged, though clarified kibbhustic ecosystem model. Pragmatic utopianism movement, has/comes out of an kibbuddhist ecosystem etc
    • Low-level got a lot more detailed with our flywheel and focus on building community and sangha
  • The next part of that how is “what” sangha?
    • What is your purpose
    • Method
    • Principles
  • We have two core offers
    • DDPs - Residencies, Programs
      • => incubator => hubs
      • ≤
    • Community for rigorous approach to transformation / getting wiser personally and collectively
      • ≤ [portal] (? A curated space for the twelve tribes of transformation everything from permaculture to mindfulness to)
      • ≤ [newsletter]
      • => research, activism, hubs, DDP …
  • Key point: trying to find the “passionate” users, dense network, product market fit.

Changes

  • Focus on DDP rather than hubs per se
    • Hubs develop on a more bottom-up basis e.g. Hub is run by a team who self-organize. Life Itself not also a landlord etc
  • Gateway info offerings plus “sangha” for advanced seekers / emerging ecosystem
    • Connected to DDP and Hub generation
  • Institute is deprioritized in “core” for now (we don’t have resource plus not closing funding). Evolve to Labs with a tighter focus, more plausible funding routes and in a quasi-independent setup
    • Big vision put on hold for now until we have more bandwidth etc … though big vision is one of the things that “sangha” likes to discuss and act on.

Run with the analogy to LessWrong

LessWrongLife Itself (if analogous to Less Wrong)
TaglineA community blog dedicated to refining the art of human rationality (2013 and 2022 tagline) LessWrong is an online forum and community dedicated to improving human reasoning and decision-making. We seek to hold true beliefs and to be effective at accomplishing our goals. Each day, we aim to be less wrong about the world than the day before. (2022 - from about page)A community and forum dedicated to exploring and acting on conscious (inner and collective) (inner) growth A community dedicated to exploring and embodying/practicing the [science] inner development and cultural evolution Conscious personal and collective evolution/progression [developing science of inner and collective growth] [deliberate development] [integral …]
AboutIn the past four decades, behavioral economists and cognitive psychologists have discovered many cognitive biases human brains fall prey to when thinking and deciding. Less Wrong is an online community for people who want to apply the discovery of biases like the conjunction fallacy, the affect heuristic, and scope insensitivity in order to fix their own thinking. Bayesian reasoning offers a way to improve on the native human reasoning style. Reasoning naively, we tend not to seek alternative explanations, and sometimes underrate the influence of prior probabilities in Bayes' theorem. Less Wrong users aim to develop accurate predictive models of the world, and change their mind when they find evidence disconfirming those models, instead of being able to explain anything. For more, see the Less Wrong about page.In the past four decades, cognitive science has converged with wisdom traditions … [integral theory, modern developmental theories] We have a new understanding of how to wake up, grow up, clean up, show up and integrate these together for a radically wiser, weller world. Life Itself is an online/offline community for people who want to apply X, Y, Z to bring wisdom to their own lives and the planet. The discoveries of integral, … Life Itself participants aim to develop their understanding and embody the growing knowledge of developmental theories for themselves and societies. === A community exploring the question: What does it look like to take seriously ontological development for ourselves and our societies. How does it help us be wiser and weller? How do we embody it? How would we organize society in light of it?

We are a community for people interested in practical integral, developmental approach to personal and collective transformation.

We are a community for people who are interested in

  • Evolution of being / consciousness
    • We all know that children “grow up” and not only physically; they grow up in their cognition, emotional, self-understanding, relation with others etc – in their “being” we could say.
    • We are a community for people enquiring and acting upon the hypothesis that this is true for humans at any age – and for our culture as a whole. And how we can practically apply this in our lives and societies.
    • We are interested in exploring both the stages and contributing factors for this evolution and especially how we can self-consciously contribute to it. For example, when we meditate we engage a conscious practice to develop greater awareness of our thoughts and feelings and deeper nature
    • We are interested in the implication and application of these ideas to our societies e.g. how we educate ourselves and our children, the form and nature of the growth we seek (inner vs outer for example)
  • What is that growing up / evolution?
    • Some people think that our evolution personally or collectively is technological we’ll become cyborgs, or go Mars etc.
      • Currently this techno-dominated is one of the most common envisioning of our future (+ve or -ve)
    • Our hypothesis is that our growth is multi-dimensional is that growth is development in one or more of our “inner” “capacities such as our cognitive, emotional, spiritual, relational etc capacities – you could term this becoming “wiser”
    • We can also grow collectively in this sense e.g. our views and values change – for example in seeing all humans as intrinsically similar and valuable (vs one group is better than another intrinsically etc)
      • for example in our view we grew as humanity when we abolished slavery (at least in its legal and state formed)
  • Our hypothesis is that this matters for X, Y, Z reason?

“Deliberate developmentalists”

Conscious Evolution

Question:

  • What are our offers?
  • What are the outcomes that really matter to us
    • Vibrant forum or equivalent because there is discourse and community (and yes content but for those people)
    • DDPs (our kind e.g. sustained multi-dimenstional growth)
    • Kibbuddhist ecosystem is developing
      • Hubs
      • Enterprises
      • Etc

Psychographics of a pioneer / shambala warrior

  • Psychographics of an active community member
  • Focus on people close to reaching “escape velocity” from the system (close to “water turning into steam”)

History of changes

  • Autumn 2021
    • Realization re Hubs (not quite working as we want)
    • Evolution of Institute to Labs
  • => (Autumn 2021 - April 2022)
    • Hubs => DDP
    • Institute => Labs
    • ?? what is our more general offer => Time to revamp
  • April 2022: Wiser discussion

Nathen Notes

Our goal is to generate a Kibuddhist ecosystem of intentional coliving spaces and transformational enterprises, lets reverse engineer:

  • We need pioneers to lead hubs & enterprises that embody a certain ethos (of inner and outer work) - e.g. Boaz, Valerie
  • To find pioneers we need to have an active group of people who are already engaged
    • Attending DDPs
    • Volunteering
    • Active in our online community
  • To find active people we must have a broader community and clear pathways for engagement
  • To find a broader community we need to have a broader offer that funnels to clear pathways for engagement
  • The journey of a guild
    • Pioneers or Masters (leading/guiding) > Apprentices (focussing in)> Pathfinders (broad interests)