Naming — alternatives to "Second Renaissance"
Naming — alternatives to "Second Renaissance"
Working doc. Started 2026-08-07. No decision made.
TL;DR
- We're considering dropping "Second Renaissance" because roughly a third of first conversations stall on is that Eurocentric?
- Six rounds have produced no candidate that decisively beats it.
- Two decisions sit above the name and need no survey: one name or two? and which register are we?
- One unanswered question could end the exercise: does the objection actually cost us anything?
- Nothing else changes: Life Itself, the podcast, the thesis, the audience, the tone.
What we want from you: read this top section and react to the two decisions. Don't vote on names yet.
Contents: Candidates · Survey design · Working history · Graveyard
Where we are
As of 2026-08-07, end of round 6.
What we're naming
Every candidate has to sit in front of this sentence. It's the "to a friend, casually" pitch from the brand deck, tightened, with the name pulled out:
"___ is a project for people who feel like the world is falling apart and are tired of the old ways of thinking and governing. Instead of just doom-scrolling about it, we're trying to work out — and actually practise — how to build the wiser world we can already sense is possible."
Test names against this, not the press version ("regenerative civilization", "beckon in the new paradigm"): test against jargon and you select for names that sound good beside jargon.
"We can already sense is possible" deliberately avoids "our hearts know is possible" — Eisenstein's book title, which this audience will read as quotation. Sense also ties back to our entry point, you feel it before you can name it. Rejected: weller (wellness adjacency) and radically (urgency we avoid).
What isn't changing
- Life Itself — the organisation
- Over the Mountains — the podcast
- The thesis — one crisis, not many; the story beneath is dying; something is trying to be born
- The audience and the tone
In play: the public name for the vision, and what the people drawn to it call themselves.
This is a re-architecture, not a rename
Renaming 2R → X is a week's work. What this doc proposes is a four-slot system — epoch, constituency, org, podcast — which touches website IA, the Substack identity, the handle, and how we each introduce ourselves at a party.
The risk in circulating it is that it reads as which name do you like? and the real question gets skipped.
The two decisions that come first
1. One name, or two?
The Renaissance had two names. The era was the Renaissance; the people were humanists. The constituency-name is the one people actually wore.
Renaissance : humanists :: [the epoch] : [the called]
For: it separates two jobs that have been fighting — naming what's happening, and naming who we are. It kills the grandiosity problem structurally, since arrogance appears when the org and the epoch share a name. And it gives us a member noun, which we've never had ("renaissancers"?).
Against: effective altruism is one name doing both jobs, and that's much of why it spread. Renaissance:humanists emerged over centuries, undesigned. We'd be asking an audience that holds about one and a half names to hold four. That may be too clever for our size.
Almost everything downstream depends on this, including whether doula is relevant at all.
2. Which register are we?
The slate contains both Practical Mystics and Civilizational Regeneration. Those aren't alternatives; they're different organisations, and they lose different people.
Are we spiritual-adjacent or civic-institutional? Who are we willing to lose?
No survey can answer this — ranking across registers just asks which brand would you rather we be. It's a forty-minute conversation, and it halves the slate. Naming can't resolve a positioning question; it can only expose one, and six rounds producing candidates this far apart is the exposure.
The question that could dissolve all of it
The brief rests on "about a third of people ask if it's Eurocentric" — an anecdote with a number attached. Two cheap tests: ten tallied conversations (does the objection stall people or start a conversation?), or an hour in Substack analytics (do they subscribe at the same rate?).
If it's a conversation-opener, the name is doing free filtering and we're solving a non-problem.
What six rounds established
1. A name must decline into a person-noun. "I'm a ___." Second Renaissance fails; effective altruist works, and that's much of why EA spread. A vision nobody can be stays a topic.
2. Metaphor vs description, not common vs proper noun. Two strategies work: borrow a referent (Renaissance, Axial Age), or say plainly what you do (Effective Altruism, Deep Adaptation). What fails is a metaphor that does neither — which killed Metamorphosis, Quickening, Chrysalis, Ripening, Metanoia and Interregnum together. They name classes of process, so anything can be one.
3. Other cultures' renaissances are a trap. Nahda, the Bengal Renaissance, the Islamic Golden Age, Tang — each relocates the Eurocentrism problem rather than solving it, with appropriation risk on top.
4. Only one referent is plural by construction. The Axial Age is the sole named civilizational turn defined by simultaneous independent emergence across separate civilizations.
Why Second Renaissance fails, and how much
Two arguments, not three; the third was withdrawn in round 6.
- Retrospective, not prospective. Michelet and Burckhardt coined "Renaissance" in the 1800s, ~400 years after the fact, once the outcome was known. Naming our own passage in advance asserts the outcome — it claims modernity-scale birth-of-a-world, from inside it.
- Brands run on vernacular, not historiography. Historiographically the Renaissance is a transition; in ordinary use the word means flourishing. So the popular read is "a great flowering is underway, and we're it."
The counterweight: it has a real referent, does both jobs in one word, and carries existing equity. Nothing on the slate beats it decisively. That's the most important sentence here, and it's why the sequence matters more than the shortlist.
The slate
The register spread is deliberate — it exists to make decision 2 visible, not because all of these are live.
Epoch / vision
| Candidate | For | Against |
|---|---|---|
| Second Renaissance (control) | Existing equity, 2R shorthand, real referent, both jobs in one word. | The two failures above. |
| Second Axial Age | The only referent plural by construction; inverts the Eurocentrism charge rather than dodging it. Names a pivot in consciousness, which is our claim. | Academic. "Axial" sounds mechanical. Keeps the era-claim, so grandiosity survives. |
| Civilizational Regeneration | Best of the say-it-on-the-tin family. New tissue, not refreshed old. Legible, forward-facing, and regenerators is a natural agent noun. | Crowded and faddish; "regenerative" is starting to greenwash. |
| Civilizational Renewal | Plain, no jargon, no Europe, no golden-age claim. Already ours — the strategy doc names the Post-Disillusionment Renewer. | Dull. Renewer is weak. Bare renewal collides with urban renewal. |
| Civilizational Repair | Tikkun olam in plain English. Deep non-European referent with moral weight. Humble in the right way. | Implies restoring a prior state; modest to the point of small. |
| Civilizational Renaissance | The adjective says the renaissance is of civilization, not of Europe. | A bigger claim than Second Renaissance, so grandiosity goes up. Nine syllables. No person-noun. |
| Renaissance Project | Project demotes the claim in one word. Good precedent: Manhattan, Human Genome, 1619. | Reads as Renaissance studies. Keeps the trigger word, so it doesn't solve the brief. |
Constituency
| Candidate | For | Against |
|---|---|---|
| Civilizational Doulas | Distinctive and ours. "A what?" is a hook, not a tax — the answer is the whole pitch in one breath. | Seven syllables. "Doula" is genuinely obscure. "Civilizational" is clunky. |
| Pragmatic Utopians | Ours. Reclaiming a slur with a hard-nosed adjective is a real move; the tension is the content. Strong agent noun. | Utopia implies a blueprint — we say not a movement with a programme — and literally means "no place". |
| Practical Mystics | Most memorable thing on any list. Real referent (Underhill; Teresa of Ávila, Gandhi). Rigour and embodiment in two words. | Narrows hard to the spiritual. Names a posture, not a thesis. |
| The Companions | Warm, ancient, effortlessly self-applied. Already in our copy: "the company to help birth the new." | Soft; wants an "of what". |
| Renewers / Regenerators | On the tin; pairs with the vision-name. | Renewer is weak — English says renewal constantly and renewer almost never. |
Shorter modifiers for doulas: World Doulas (warmest, loses the rigour signal) · Axial Doulas (ties both names into one system; depends on the epoch-name being public). Rejected list in round 5.
For the group discussion, three per slot, chosen to sit far apart so the register question surfaces:
- Epoch: Second Renaissance (control) · Second Axial Age · Civilizational Regeneration
- Constituency: Civilizational Doulas · Pragmatic Utopians · Renewers
Tests
- Person-noun. "I'm a ___." Can they say it without wincing?
- Hostile mouth. Every name gets said about us by someone we don't control: "they're the second renaissance lot" · "she's one of those practical mystics." That sentence is what circulates, not our tagline.
- Stranger. Five seconds. If it needs explaining, does the explanation sell or cost? Hooks are explanation that converts.
- Spelling. Say it, ask them to type it. Our own deck failed this six times:
secondrennaisance.org. - Podcast. "Over the Mountains, a podcast from ___."
- Grandiosity. Does it promise that we personally are delivering civilization?
- Distinctiveness. One specific thing, or a class anything could belong to?
Open questions
| # | Question | Owner | By |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Does the Eurocentrism objection actually cost us? Ten tallied conversations, or an hour in Substack analytics. | ? | ? |
| 2 | One name or two? | Group | Next call |
| 3 | Which register? | Group | Next call |
| 4 | What does switching cost? Nobody has written it down: secondrenaissance.net, @secondrenaissance.is, Seeds of 2R and its ~1.1k subscribers, 2R shorthand everywhere, the brand deck, back-catalogue episodes. An uncosted rename always looks cheaper than it is. | ? | ? |
| 5 | Do we keep "Second" at all? | Group | — |
Recommended sequence
- Close question 1. Cheap, and it may end the exercise.
- Settle the register. Halves the slate.
- Settle one-name-or-two. Determines whether we need a constituency noun at all.
- Then survey 3–4 close variants within the chosen register, against Second Renaissance as control.
If forced to call it today: keep Second Renaissance, add doulas as the constituency noun it has never had, and spend the energy on the magazine. A rebrand that doesn't clearly win is a year of switching cost for a lateral move. This flips the moment question 1 shows the objection is costing us conversions.
Survey structure
Who. Substack subscribers and podcast listeners — not friends, not the team. People who meet the name cold. A cut of people who've never heard of us is better still.
Test the two slots separately. Comparing an epoch-name to a constituency-name compares different jobs.
Keep Second Renaissance as a control. Otherwise we learn which alternative people prefer, not whether any beats what we have. It's the only question that can tell us not to rebrand.
Four questions, in order:
- First reaction, open text. Name alone: "What do you think this is?" Reveals whether the Eurocentrism objection disappears or migrates.
- Wince test. "Finish the sentence: I'm a ___." Constituency slot only.
- Explanation test. After the pitch: "Does the name make more sense now, or less?" Separates hooks from taxes.
- Preference, last. Ranked, so it's informed rather than aesthetic.
Preference rankings between abstract names are weak signal — people pick the prettiest word — so open-ended comes first.
Don't show names beside logos (that tests the design), explain ourselves before Q1 (destroys the only cold read), or ask people to justify reactions (the unreasoned response is the data).
Split the sample. Half see the pitch before any name, half only at Q3. The pitch-first group is the insider read — the people who'll actually use the word. The cold group is the stranger read. A sharp disagreement between them means the name only works once you already know.
Working history
How we got here. Chronological. Skippable.
The brief
"Second Renaissance" is problematic because of its association with Eurocentrism. Roughly a third of people we say it to come back with is that colonialist? Does it mean the next civilizational rebirth happens in Europe? The answer is no, but it takes thirty seconds and we lose people before we get there. We're changing the name, not what we're about. Domains and handles set aside for now.
Source material: 2r/Second Renaissance Brand Narrative Visual.pdf, strategy/second-renaissance-strategy.md, 2r/brand.md.
Critique of the brief
It's a defect report, not a brief — all negative, no positive criterion, which is why round 1 produced infinite bland globally-neutral names.
The objection may be misdiagnosed. Is the problem Europe, or grandiosity? "Second Renaissance" claims we are producing a civilizational golden age — a large claim from a farmhouse. "Is that Eurocentric?" may be the polite form of who are you to say that? If so, Second Axial Age fixes nothing.
Four things the brief omitted, all of which became central: the member noun; the adjective test ("that's very ___"); switching cost; and whether the moment-name is meant to be the org name.
What the brand is (read-back of the narrative deck)
- Thesis: one crisis, not many. The civilizational story underneath is dying; something is trying to be born inside the breakdown.
- Emotional entry: you feel it before you can name it. People arrive with intuition and no vocabulary. First job is to give them words.
- Shape: death → threshold → birth. The journey map runs: something isn't right → you already feel it → seeking → vision & diagnosis → belonging → practice → catalyst → build a hub.
- Central metaphor: midwifery. Not leaders, not a movement — a doula accompanies a passage they cannot control, holds grief and joy at once, has no clinical authority and no programme.
- Offer: vision + practice + company. Four doorways: podcast, white papers, magazine, courses.
- Tone: poet-philosopher leading, lucid thinker grounding.
- Note: "constellation, not movement" already answers the Eurocentrism charge. The current name contradicts it.
Round 2 — moment or practice?
Are we naming the vision (Second Renaissance, Second Axial Age) or the practice (doula-ing)?
| Job | Test it must pass | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| The moment | Borrowed resonance — must mean something before you explain it | Renaissance, Axial Age, Enlightenment, Neolithic Revolution |
| The practice | Concrete — says the activity | Effective Altruism, Deep Adaptation, Extinction Rebellion |
The best names collapse both columns. Effective Altruism names a vision and an activity at once. Renaissance does it too — the time between worlds, and the act of rebirthing a civilization. That double duty is why it has held despite the Europe problem.
The disqualifier: metamodern, integral, the metacrisis, quickening, natality all need defining before they mean anything. A name requiring a definition taxes every conversation.
Second Axial Age emerged here and survived every round since. Jaspers' Axial Age (~800–200 BCE) is defined by Confucius, the Buddha, Socrates, the Hebrew prophets and Zoroaster arising independently and simultaneously across separate civilizations. Already public (Cousins coined "Second Axial Age"; Armstrong and Cobb use it), so we'd join a term rather than own one — exactly as with Renaissance. Costs: less known, "axial" sounds mechanical, and scholars dispute whether Jaspers over-generalised.
Practice-names generated: Deep Renewal · Civilizational Doula · Threshold Work · The Great Work · Practising the Future · Endings and Beginnings.
Round 3 — the group board, and two dimensions
Four of us contributed names. Two dimensions emerged: name the moment or the group, and go allegorical or concrete.
| Allegorical | Concrete | |
|---|---|---|
| Moment | The Ripening · Aurora · Phoenix · Chrysalis · Crowning · Ouro/Boros · Age of the Serpent · Nova Nacents · Over the Mountains · White Rose Black Flag | Second Axial Age · Civilizational Renaissance · The Age of Rebirth · Metamorphosis |
| Group | Companions · Pilgrims of the Sacred World · Xing Doula | Civilizational Doula · Doulas of Modernity · Emergence Doulas |
Three readings, all of which held:
- The board was lopsided toward allegory — the brief's failure mode returning. Left to run, group taste lands somewhere beautiful and undefined.
- The dimensions aren't independent. Allegorical ≈ meaning we must install; concrete ≈ meaning we borrow. It's a cost axis, not a style axis. A concrete name can be delivered lyrically; a lyrical name can't be made rigorous afterwards.
- Moment vs group is a false choice — they stack. This became the two-name architecture.
Kill reasons are in the graveyard. The finding: the concrete-moment quadrant was nearly empty, and that's where our differentiator lives.
Round 4 — Over the Mountains, and the constituency turn
OTM vs Second Renaissance fail in opposite directions. 2R is all thesis and no humility. OTM is all humility and no thesis — someone hearing it learns we're on a journey, not what we think is true.
Feel-read on OTM: warm, patient, wistful, folk rather than academic. No Europe problem, no explanation cost. But mountains connote withdrawal — ascent, solitude, going away from civilization, when our thesis is worldly and social. A doula doesn't go over a mountain. And it's a destination-frame: the good place is elsewhere, later. Quietly escapist for a project whose credibility rests on being in the mess with people. Verdict: right for the podcast, wrong as a master brand.
The common-noun rejection. Interregnum, Metamorphosis and The Ripening are all very poor — weak in sense and not distinct. Correct, with one cause: they name classes of process. This also closed off the other-cultures'-renaissances route.
Group-name candidates: The Invisible College (the 1640s network of natural philosophers with no building and no charter, who became the Royal Society — distributed, humble, pre-institutional; but reads academic) · Civilizational Doulas · The Companions · The Long Work · Life Itself — raised and ruled out, because the brand is for the vision and the people called to it, which is not Life Itself. That ruling-out is what turned this from naming an organisation into naming a constituency, and produced the Renaissance:humanists architecture.
Round 5 — toward a slate
Civilizational Doulas shortlisted. Renaissance Project — the project move is smart but it reads as Renaissance studies and keeps the trigger word. Civilizational Renaissance — fixes Europe only.
Shorter modifiers for doulas: World and Axial survived; Earth, Culture, Civic, Modernity, Planetary, Threshold and Future did not, and bare "The Doulas" collides with birth doulas.
The formal name needn't be the spoken one. EA runs "effective altruism" formally and "EAs" in conversation. Civilizational doulas can be the definition while people say doulas.
Round 6 — say it on the tin
Prompt: "if I had to say in one word what we are, we are renew-ers. And what we want is civilizational renewal."
This forced the metaphor vs description refinement now at the top: the earlier "common nouns are dead" verdict was too broad, since EA has no historical referent either and works because it describes. It also withdrew the backwards-pointing objection to renaissance — renewal keeps civilization as the subject and renews it, using things from the past and bringing new things, which is what the Renaissance did.
Shorter modifiers than "civilizational": World (plain, global — and the World Renewal ceremonies of northwest California are an unexpectedly good referent, though living traditions, so leaning on it explicitly would be appropriation) · Deep (does what integral was doing without the Wilber freight) · The Renewal (mirrors "the Renaissance" without the word). Rejected: cultural (traditionalist-coded), civic (local democracy), social (Steiner), planetary (ecological drift), human (personal development), great (Great Reset proximity).
On the modifiers proposed: integral signals a subculture and narrows. Wise is presumptuous as a self-label but fine attached to the goal. Pragmatic is a good differentiator but dry — and pragmatic utopians beats pragmatic renewers, because there the noun dreams and the adjective grounds.
The constraint that survived every modifier: renewer is a weak agent noun. English says renewal constantly and renewer almost never. Which argues for the two-name architecture — "we work on civilizational renewal" is legible, and the constituency keeps its own noun.
Six constructions brainstormed: [grounding adjective + aspirational noun] (the EA formula) · [scale adjective + noun of work] · verb-forward gerund · relationship to time · relationship by posture · occupational/guild forms.
Candidates with real force, beyond those on the slate:
- World repair → repairers / menders — tikkun olam in plain English. Deep non-European referent. But implies restoring a prior state, and is modest to the point of small.
- Worldmakers — pedigree (Goodman, Ways of Worldmaking), strong noun. Collides with worldbuilding; a bit grand.
- Civilizational apprentices — the humility play. Unusual and disarming, but may undersell.
- Good ancestors — deep time, humble, resonant. Krznaric's book effectively owns it.
Rejected: worldbuilders (gaming) · civilizational healers (woo, claims authority) · transitioners (Transition Towns) · civilization builders (colonial, or video-game) · civilizational design (technocratic).
Appendix — the graveyard
Every name already considered and killed, so we don't re-suggest them. Rounds 1–2, plus the round-3 group board (whose kill list, with fuller reasons, is in the working history).
The pattern: almost all of round 1 was a private metaphor rather than a public referent — mood over meaning.
| Name | Verdict |
|---|---|
| Quickening | Zero pre-existing meaning. A mood, not a claim. |
| Natality | Arendt's term for the capacity to begin. Needs defining. |
| Metamorphosis · Chrysalis · Metanoia · Interregnum · The Ripening | Common nouns naming classes of process. Vague by construction. |
| Crowning | Obstetric, and double-reads as coronation. |
| The Turning · The Great Birth | Too close to Macy's Great Turning. |
| The Crossing · The Narrows · First Light · The Unfolding · Becoming | Mood-words with no referent. |
| Threshold | Precise, badly overused in this space. |
| Bardo | Exact concept, non-European — but esoteric, plus appropriation risk. |
| Compost · Fallow | Unglamorous; too passive for a build-it brand. |
| Second Spring · Second Genesis · Second Birth · Rebirth | Referents generic or religious, not historical. |
| Nova · Aurora | Empty vessels. Aurora is also a Roman goddess and heavily used commercially. |
| Worlding | Jargon, which we banned. |
| Seedtime · Germinal · Rootstock | Pretty, no public referent. |
| What Comes Next | Exactly what people search for; impossible to own. |
| Honest Hope | A description, not a name. |
| Second Reformation · Second Enlightenment | Euro and Christian; Schmachtenberger has the second. |
| Second Neolithic | Reads as regression. |
| Ouro / Boros · Phoenix | Closed cycles — the same thing returns. The opposite of our thesis. |
| White Rose Black Flag | The Weiße Rose were executed in 1942. Appropriates martyrdom; reads anarchist. |
| Age of the Serpent | Global upside, but in Anglophone markets serpent means deceiver. |
| Xing Doula · Nova Nacents | Unpronounceable or misspelled. |
| Doulas of Modernity · Emergence Doulas | Parses as serving modernity; Emergence Magazine collision. |
| Deep Renewal · Threshold Work · The Great Work · The Long Work | Practice-names; either taken (Berry) or common-noun weak. |
| The Invisible College | Genuinely good fit — distributed, humble, pre-institutional — but reads academic and is loosely used elsewhere. Revivable. |
Still alive, in other slots:
| Name | Where |
|---|---|
| Over the Mountains | The podcast. Journey-frame is right there, wrong for a master brand. |
| The Constellation · Good Company | Constituency ideas; both feed Companions. |