Seeds of Renaissance — top-level strategy (10–20 years)

Logical Thinking Process (LTP) run on 2026-11-17 with the reasoncommons ltp-v2 skill, from the brief and David Joseph's goal tree. Standing: accepted for now, not proof. Full state: sor-top-level.ltp.yaml.

Stage: Goal [x] > Reality [~] > Conflicts [ ] > Future [ ] > Actions [ ]

TL;DR

  • Goal: seed a civilisational renaissance — within 20 years, at least one region or society has substantially shifted to the new paradigm, carried by a self-sustaining movement around a shared story of civilisational crisis and renewal.
  • Our part: the story itself, its spread, and a committed community that holds it. Practice we curate; pockets, links across the wider ecosystem, resources and action we share with others.
  • Main constraint: SoR stays viable and grows its own team and hubs only as fast as others take up the story.

Goal tree (2026-11-17)

Tags give SoR's stance: OURS (we lead), CURATE (we point to others' work), SHARED (we contribute alongside others), OTHERS (we leave it). The tree lists everything the goal needs, whoever does it; our part is in the tags, not in what is cut.

G  Seed a civilisational renaissance: within 20 years,
   at least one region or society has substantially
   shifted its foundational views, values and practices
   toward a wiser, weller world, carried by a
   self-sustaining, plural movement around a shared story
   of civilisational crisis and renewal.

CSF1 A coherent mythos (crisis-and-renewal story and
     vision) that moves people; a common core, not a
     creed, that many traditions recognise         [OURS]
CSF2 The story spreads beyond us, including beyond
     the already-converted                         [OURS]
CSF3 People have practices that grow the inner
     capacities the shift needs                    [CURATE]
CSF4 A committed community holds and stewards the
     story, without a guru, with a bond strong
     enough to sustain action                      [OURS]
CSF5 Pockets form and last                         [SHARED]
CSF6 Others beyond SoR carry renewal too, and
     connect with each other and with us  (draft)  [SHARED]
CSF7 Resources flow to pioneers and pockets        [SHARED]
CSF8 The story turns into coordinated action and,
     over time, institutions, while steadying the
     transition through breakdown                  [SHARED]

Main constraint: SoR stays viable and grows its own team
and hubs only as fast as others take up the story.

Necessary conditions under our three CSFs (agreed 2026-11-17):

CSF1 Coherent mythos                                 [OURS]
 1.1 Names root causes (views, values), not only
     symptoms
 1.2 Pairs the challenge with a powerful, positive
     vision that pulls people forward
 1.3 Keeps modernity's gifts, moves beyond its limits
 1.4 Emotionally and culturally accessible
 1.5 Small core, clearly separate from optional layers
 1.6 Many traditions recognise the core as theirs and
     add their own expression
 1.7 Shows each person a part to play in ordinary
     life, linking inner change to outer action

CSF2 The story spreads                               [OURS]
 2.1 People who sense the breakdown find it and
     recognise it as theirs                [sensers]
 2.2 Speaks across class, politics and education,
     not only the reflective milieu         [public]
 2.3 Others retell and use it without us  [carriers]
 2.4 Core stays recognisable as expressions adapt
 2.5 Keeps credibility outside; not captured by one
     political camp or written off as a cult
 2.6 People can see the vision lived: credible,
     visible examples (people, pockets)
 2.7 Shows up in public life through collective
     action (e.g. a party, referenda, campaigns)

CSF4 Committed community holds the story             [OURS]
 4.1 Clear way in, and a way to go deeper at the
     commitment each person chooses
 4.2 Enough people commit deeply to carry the work
                                          [pioneers]
 4.3 Stewardship is shared and renews; the story is
     a revisable commons that outlasts founders
 4.4 Can disagree and handle conflict without
     splitting
 4.5 Belonging gives real value, so people stay; the
     bond never turns into control

Primary audiences (falling out of the NCs): sensers (people who already feel the breakdown), carriers (artists, writers, teachers, faith and community leaders), pioneers (people who commit deeply), and the wider public.

What success looks like. 20 years: a region or society has switched to the new paradigm. 10-year marker (assumption): thousands of people, dozens of lasting pockets, 5+ countries, counted movement-wide with SoR as one contributor. A person counts if they hold the story as their own and act on it in a group; a pocket is 5+ people lasting 2+ years. David's measure stays: durable adoption by others, not activity.

Mapping to David's tree. CSF1 = his 1 + 2 (and 8.6 pull factors); CSF2 = 6.3, 6.5; CSF3 = 3; CSF4 = 5; CSF5 = 4; CSF6 = 6.1, 6.2, 6.4, 6.7; CSF7 = 4.5, 5.2; CSF8 = 7 + 8.

Theory of change (draft, in a few lines)

Many people feel the old world breaking down, but that sense is incoherent and varied, and so rarely coheres into action. SoR offers a middle ground: a coherent mythos, held by a community without a guru, that people can gather round if they wish. As the story spreads and people take it up, pockets form and link with others doing renewal work, and the movement grows able to act systematically — and, over time, to shift a whole society.

Current reality, conflicts, future reality, actions

Not yet done. Candidate conflict already named: how strong the bond should be — an open place to hang out, an effective-altruism-like middle, or a religion-like strong bind (CSF4).

Open questions

  1. CSF6: what it means in a tree about SoR, given the movement will be far bigger than SoR.
  2. Primary audiences: first cut above (sensers, carriers, pioneers, public); sharpen at the near-term level.
  3. Bond strength (CSF4) — for the conflicts stage.