⚠ Switch to EXCALIDRAW VIEW in the MORE OPTIONS menu of this document. ⚠

Excalidraw Data

Text Elements

Effective Altruism ^h2Nydze0EaVDN5RLWDbWV

SJWs / Climate Activists etc ^7nzTIGoj88XF3h6uxK_Sd

Contemplatives

Eco-dharmas etc ^ZlvK_pWUQzaGi_NlZNDRN

Integral Altruism / PU ^ahKs2ysuh46S75wxowDnB

Second Renaissance ^EHzgd0_KsyntVA9XDEnh9

Common to all is a move to integral/teal thinking ^2QUKaBGwSWJ7ukyf1wGCC

For EA'ers it is getting paradigmatic change and imprortance of left quadrants e.g. cultural evolution

Transcending and including: rationality, effectiveness in narrow sense ^bJYbakpuf0lD06dMj22ol

Adding back truth-iness and universalism. Transcending and including relativism

Getting over: identity politics / wokeism / reactivity / wrong-making / victim&perpertrator dynamics ^E7UB5LMSIu6ArweqC-Ct9

Adding back the "plural" i.e. systems change and cultural evolution.

How do we bring intellectual rigor (i.e. head) as well as heart. ^QpopyS3OEGIF-X8xaqxUf

Inner ^WI8mbJkve6fz-n5X9nQzG

Outer ^8YCEojT_BtFub91faaw1P

Singular ^t7ac8plhRywDKmSRQ4xzt

Plural ^idKrLheJvIiNlmxZDqdhZ

Systems e.g. institutions ^9qAV5Xky_6gU-WaMkqxZ4

Technology ^PbJKY-VZSlh61oqNI_QSS

EA ^B-TLEKSIGCwO_1lqIJaAX

SJW ^Eqm8RAUjwo8BS9m18mlvl

Dharma ^f5WpXbCk0nLM2IcoFBQeC

Waking up ^F5V__P9ANzer5sIiYoEU_

Cog Complexity ^0wUF9i4F4IjtnxoGiq3Tq

Cleaning up ^X_8ca_QHN4Vs70oHsmgtn

EA ^ra0mZUaJHdkAnmJWl8-BK

Growing up ^SMUjAiswIFC2Y0qYtHVyN

Dharma ^0z8Hi2CsH5kfG_CpvrADb

SJW ^AH1wubm_YC0X1iy3mSssQ

Showing up ^UO3EY_BazaLeXsluM0a13

Postmodern ^Ce6gp59Yj-ziO95xeljWN

Modern ^oRQ1eCrasuokcI_rq22ZA

Hmm, not doing too well on climate change … wonder if making all those trump voters wrong is helping … ^EZDyHLXA3D7qBGVxnmUtd

Why are we failing on AI x-risk? Hmmm, what about complex systems? What about collective action problems? ^Ejr6mhjw-wux6gjuU2ygh

Mindfulness is great … But how do we engage with power and affect change at some scale? ^v35fGLfqV_d87Mwnc63m2

Changemakers ^ItNiG55bdLFE5YKGeAyco

Movement ^Lztn1s2xAQWCwo0q-Cou3

Philosophy ^MeoRpqa6jcbGdZ78SPymE

Sociological Context ^wQqg1RUEkISR2vmWyPFd2

Utilitarianism [moral framework] ^s4YLUJ7_G1oCHzhVJqOZW

Effective Altruism ^WjIfO8y3fzP81uZwvA4kJ

2R (movement) ^3oe2-OseT81efweYJoEJT

Rise of engineering mindset & wealth in tech and quant finance ^kc8xVufOE9yaugM3aF03u

(why does it have social traction / power) ^dv6JsNxZ3SpscWy_OjKA1

Pragmatic Utopianism ^W_UzCxJM86_P0LBphUumF

Ameliorative within current system largely (other than more tech - if tech is transformative) ^q1qLTje2D76bHNxUH8Vld

Focus on paradigmatic change … i.e. "radical" (at the root) ^IP4v185mxZoYy0GBSHYwl

Reason based, utils metric ^oZsf2ijfh7TnPBVOCtIwZ

Pragmatism as philosophy Wisdom-like orientation to sensemaking in fact of complexity etc ^YjmGUwk0gBRdp4onwVvNM

Wisdom (?) (Value-ception & Virtue) ^KBdBv9L07BxMCopltf6XK

Materialist Reason ^Jc9qTw-GHtS4WCgZoTt8N

Meaning Crisis ^Vzc7P1TU8Y-wGnmXwTwbV

Wicked (collective action) problems ^J3bKnWx6AcVXhZsCLNDkl

and/or ^MKLvztj7Cy9qZA0TUEtGn

Care about utils ^uIdXE41bd2vmWM0kYUS_t

Care about utils ^6wtu1AicvGccmf15pGA6Y

Care about x-risk ^BxJTaNFufXAYNSWYBd0Jg

Care about x-risk ^NIyZlmy7ahxaJOpqzhnCm

Care about AI risk ^o6_GVC4xy9ynHRjkrORE3

Care about AI risk ^yG5P0hDrSnfYnFOU-Lugh

Look at alignment problem (engineering problem) ≥ solve the control problem ^uiYj2XLPrFFgO4V9N2ziE

Look at alignment problem (engineering problem) – let's solve the control problem ^7Mz1Cf-RknlyX1dR9ygTN

Care about tech governance ^cXJbKZY1lG2TfIK-AoXdx

Care about tech governance ^9o-fPZfDz6zI_ZDnJ6RKH

Care about collective action problems ^vtyj8redqskkledvlodgl

Care about collective action problems ^lvINCh_0c9ml0sOom8Dy6

Care about cultural evolution ^J739eTqxCJ9sgI_OELEkb

Care about cultural evolution ^sZzhISsUP7vQUXsTRXV9H

Care about inner development, memetics & movement building ^eJRNvIHrONJu7_kS-hqlq

Care about inner development … ^HzAjBL1cWmEgkKsG6GVzo

maximizing long-term utils means i care about … ^uac_VRhSxkrRJltzLRgHh

(1) maximizing long- term utils means i care about … ^25VBcLXxKSHLJxEgTJm4d

Choose an area e.g. AI x-risk as proximate, tech-y & well resourced ^ENqC9-5W6vK44PoFjwPw8

(2) Choose an area e.g. AI x-risk as proximate, tech-y, sexy and well resourced ^6nDpKIJDS4W8OMtnntIyp

Alignment problem maybe not solvable. Plus race to bottom for states & companies ≥ safety sidelined. Individual action & good intentions won't be enough … ^FKR86N-cAqYbsgjsx405r

(3) Realize alignment problem may not be solvable. Also see race to bottom dynamics (e.g. sideling of safety in AI startups). Individual action and good intentions won't be enough … ^hnJFeltEt2RjVcov21XWc

Realize this is a collective action problem at planetary scale ^w-oq0KfDTu-7Zr_qt1Sh3

Realize that this is a collective action problem at planetary scale ^nB5Ir9N0JjrpSVh5okcIa

Realize that solving collectivce action problems at planetary scale likely require a breakthrough in views and values … a shift in cultural paradigm … ^pdm4hbkyQfArzFJvvvsov

Realize that solving collective action problems at planetary scale likely require a breakthrough in views and values … a shift in cultural paradigm … ^b6sBxipCQeKuXnVMXfBBr

Cultural evolution comes via a vanguard … & multi-dim inner dev is key to forming, sustaining those and creating new worldviews etc ^PB11Bm6ieBtwGrG7LTXDd

Cultural evolution comes via a vanguard … and multi-dim inner development is key to forming, sustaining those and creating the new worldviews etc ^5o1q0vxd5a-09wGTihFmT

How can I solve AI problem? ^PEmJ9aCYUqZSRE0awDHz5

How can I solve AI problem? ^iFhGcMgge1pFRs-V1XRwM

Rationality ^VwKiRb4jO8Z_knpHRWjSL

Integral ^ZF48dqPXP–406_bus753

Integral (philosophy) ^pCT2vFhlHJRXtcAYVkrRv

maps to ^sysPndBbVWPxqKSlvMbmC

Effective Altruism ^u0R_Pf5PSLMrLV_R6m2to

Pragmatic Utopianism (Second Renaissance) ^xnK9cCnB53MioNhPuVaWS

Effective Altruism ^SETv1S8O9RzR4MQNoJJsF

Effective Altruism ^wsShIrR6IYbj1ey6jljfC

Second Renaissance ^up8l44Ltb2GEvaKQ7LKqm

Second Renaissance ^LYASMlJPS883slVylB4tU

(and Conscious Coliving, Development Spaces etc) ^oz2d8uSqwz1HRYd8ttRG4

(and Conscious Coliving, Development Spaces etc) ^URElNnQ_j_xRjEdYK7KEz